SVM116050 - Case Selection, Handling and Settlement: Key Principles – Case Handling



The aim should be to establish the facts as quickly as possible.

You should use those facts to inform your valuation conclusions. Valuations should rest on facts rather than on suppositions. The best arguments in the world are likely to fail before a tax tribunal unless the facts to back them up are available. If we cannot quickly get the facts we need to present a strong argument, we need to consider whether our fact finding is well – aimed and likely to assist in any litigation that may become necessary. This is the time to consider whether our chances of success are good; and, if they are poor, to withdraw early.

Preparation for litigation should not be left until all chances of a negotiated settlement have been exhausted. It should start much earlier. Early consideration of the chances of success in any possible litigation can bring important efficiency savings. In practice, this means getting the right facts quickly (if necessary using information powers). As it may not always be obvious what the right facts are, obtaining some initial litigation advice will help to direct the fact finding process.

Handling cases in a way that prepares for litigation assists in reaching agreed settlements. Focusing on key, strong arguments shows that we know our strengths and that we are developing a credible case in the event of litigation. We sometimes undermine good legal arguments by mixing them with poor ones – early advice and preparedness to litigate substantially mitigates this risk.


Additional Guidance: SVM150000