PSI3.3.10 - Membership of Schemes: Directors - Controlling Directors of Investment Companies - Reason for Refusal


(This archived guidance relates to HMRC discretionary practice before the 6th April 2006. For current guidance on Registered Pension Schemes see the Registered Pension Schemes Manual)

Our main objections to schemes for controlling directors and members of controlling families of investment companies are:
  1. a pension should be a replacement for income foregone because a person can no longer continue his or her occupation. This need for income replacement does not normally apply to investment income. Also the director's remuneration from such a company is more a return on capital invested than a payment for services.
  2. the terms of section 644 ICTA 88 prevent a "controlling director" of an investment company from taking out a personal pension relating to the remuneration the director receives from that source. It is therefore consistent to take a similar line with occupational pension schemes.