CTM80680 - Consortia: group relief: example: claim by consortium member and by group member and potential group claims

In this example ICTA88/S410 (arrangement for transfer of company to another group or consortium) and ICTA88/S413 (7) to (10) (entitlement to profits and assets tests) do not apply. Apportionments are on a time basis.

The consortium and group structure is as shown in the diagram at CTM80590.

Facts

CH is a holding company owned by members of a consortium L (60%) and X (40%). CH holds 90% of the ordinary share capital of CT1 a trading subsidiary. CT2 and CT3 are 100% trading subsidiaries of CH.

L owns 75% of the shares in S2. The other 25% are not held by any company in P’s group.

This part of the consortium and group structure has existed for many years.

All the companies except S2 draw up accounts to 31 December.

For accounting periods to 31 December 2000:

  • CT1 has profits of £40,000.
  • CT2and CT3 each have losses of £3,000.
  • CH has neither profit nor loss.

S2 has losses of £19,000 for accounting period 12 months to 30 June 2001.

CT1 makes a consortium claim in respect of S2’s losses.

ICTA88/S405 (4) ( CTM80585) applies because there is the potential for CT1 to make group claims in respect of CT2’s and CT3’s losses. It could claim £6,000 in total, £3,000 from each. So for the purposes of calculating the amount of consortium relief CT1 can claim, its total profits are £34,000 (£40,000 minus £6,000).

Procedure

The provisions about apportionment to overlapping periods (ICTA88/S403A - CTM80215) interact with those about consortium shares (ICTA88/S403C - CTM80545) and those about surrenders by group members ICTA88/S406 - CTM80560. A restriction is also needed because the consortium company could claim make group claims from fellow group companies (ICTA88/S405 - CTM80585).

The claim

CT1 can claim consortium relief from S2 because S2 is in the same group as the link company L. ICTA88/S406 applies ( CTM80550).

The overlapping period ( CTM80225) is 6 months ended 31 December 2000.

S2’s surrenderable amount for the accounting period ended 30 June 2001 is £19,000. Under ICTA88/S403A (3)(b) that is not reduced by reference to ICTA88/S403C.

S2 has made no prior surrenders so its ‘unused part of the surrenderable amount for the overlapping period’ ( CTM80235) is the same as its ‘surrenderable amount for the overlapping period’ ( CTM80230). It is:

6/12x£19,000=£9,500

CT1’s total profits for its accounting period to 31 December 2000 are £34,000 as above. However ICTA88/S403C (3) (CTM80545) limits this to L’s share (‘relevant fraction’ ICTA88/S406(6) - CTM80560) of CT1’s profits for the accounting period.

This is:

60% x 90% = 54%x£34,000=£18,360

So CT1’s ‘unrelieved part of the claimant’s total profits for the overlapping period (CTM80230) (which is also the same as its ‘total profits for the overlapping period’ as it has made no prior claims) is:

6/12x£18,360=£9,180

The amount that can be surrendered/claimed is the smaller of £9,500 and £9,180 = £9,180.