AH0635 - Preparation for Hearing: Evidence from other sources


If you have not already done so, you should also think of the likelihood of relevant information being available from other sources. There could be information held elsewhere in the HMRC or available from outside sources. The HMRC obtains a great deal of information by use of its third party information powers (see the TPI Directory). There is also much information available on the Internet.

If you have an appeal from a company director against the amendment of his self-assessment there might, for example, be very relevant information in the Directors' reports attached to the company's accounts held by the office dealing with the company's affairs. Similarly, where an employee is claiming a deduction for expenses in his self-assessment, the employer will have important information about the scope of the employee's duties.

And the papers for the purchaser of land may give a very different picture of the transaction from that put forward by the vendor whose profit on disposal is being assessed. Those papers might show that an interview with the purchaser would be worthwhile. This is not to suggest that the files for other parties should invariably be consulted as part of the preparation for a contested appeal, but you should at least consider looking at them.