AH3901 - Appeals Handbook: Appeals against penalties and surcharge: types of penalty


There are many different penalties which may be imposed under the Taxes Acts. Most are determined by an officer of the Revenue & Customs (sometimes following a direction from the Commissioners) and others are determined by the Commissioners. See AH3800 and subsequent paragraphs regarding determinations by the Commissioners.

A penalty may be a fixed amount or it may be an amount not exceeding a specified statutory maximum. All maximum penalties are abated to arrive at the appropriate amount (TMA70/S100(1))

There are rights of appeal against all of these penalties and these are discussed in the following paragraphs. Where a penalty is determined by an authorised officer of the Revenue & Customs the right of appeal is generally to the Commissioners. Where it is imposed by the Commissioners the right of appeal is generally to the High Court in England and Wales or to the Court of Session in Scotland.

The more common circumstances in which a penalty is charged are listed in AH3902 to AH3906.