AH3810 - Penalty Proceedings: Initial failure to furnish information etc required by a notice or provisions specified in TMA70/S98


An initial penalty of up to £300 for the failure to deliver a return or document, or to furnish particulars, information, a certificate or record etc required by a notice or provisions specified in the Table at TMA70/S98 may be awarded by the Commissioners under TMA70/S98(1)(i). Once the Commissioners have awarded an initial penalty further, daily, penalties under S98(1)(ii) can be determined by an officer of Revenue & Customs.

The notices and provisions specified in the Table at TMA70/S98 include

  • a notice issued under TMA70/S16
  • a notice issued under TMA70/S20
  • a return of “benefits” on form P11D
  • a notice issued under Regulation 97 The Income Tax (Pay as You Earn) Regulations 2003.

Under TMA70/S100C an officer of Revenue & Customs, authorised to do so, may commence proceedings before the General or Special Commissioners for the award of the initial penalty. The authorisation made by Commissioners for HMRC covers all Inspectors (see EM4902).

Proceedings must be approved personally by a Band B1 Inspector but it is not, however, necessary for that person to be named in and sign the information laid before the Commissioners (AH3840).

In cases involving the failure to comply with a TMA70/Section 20(3) notice you should make a report with the file in accordance with EM2505 for approval to commence penalty proceedings.

Failure remedied

Where the failure is to make a return etc on service of a notice specified in TMA70/S98, column 1 of the Table, no penalty may be imposed once the failure has been remedied.

Where the failure is to provide information etc under a provision specified in TMA70/S98, column 2 of the Table, (returns etc required by legislation or regulations without the need for a notice from the Inspector, for example P11Ds) it is only the continuing daily penalties that cannot be imposed after the failure is remedied. The initial penalty of up to £300 can still be imposed.

Thus the summons from the Commissioners now acts as a final warning' for column 1 failures but not column 2 failures.

Daily penalties

Guidance on the determination of daily penalties following the imposition of an initial penalty is at EM4900+.