AH0970 - Commissioners’ Hearing: The case for HMRC: Developments during hearing


You may find that your outline of the case, prepared beforehand in the light of facts then known and the contentions expected, requires radical alteration in order that facts newly elicited or fresh aspects of the appellant's case brought out may be properly dealt with.

It is important that you reply adequately to the case for the appellant as it stands at the conclusion of the evidence given on his behalf.

When a point is raised unexpectedly by the other side, or when a new contention is put forward, all the implications of which are not immediately evident, it may be appropriate to seek an adjournment so that the new points may be properly dealt with. Similarly, if you consider that the appellant's case as presented differs materially from that known to you prior to the hearing, you should draw this to the Commissioners' attention and request an adjournment.

This course should only be taken where it appears essential to do so in the interests of HMRC.