AH0835 - Commissioners’ Hearings: Appellant's Opening: Your role


During the opening, you should take detailed notes. If relevant facts are omitted, it will be up to you to bring them out in cross-examination. You should also note any points which will require answer or comment in your presentation of HMRC's case.

If there is any material mis-statement of fact or if it is alleged incorrectly that a particular fact is admitted by HMRC, you should immediately draw the error to the Commissioners' attention.

Where a material document is put in during the opening statement which you had not previously seen, you should at once ask for a copy, and if the copy is not forthcoming you should ask to see and peruse the original. If the document is of such complexity or importance that it cannot be adequately considered and its bearing on HMRC case properly dealt with at the hearing, you should request an adjournment for this to be done. Your request will have added force if you had asked to see the document before the hearing.

During the opening statement and, indeed, throughout the whole course of the hearing, you should observe carefully any comments made or questions put by the Commissioners, noting any which suggest points for or against your case. This will enable you, during your submissions, to emphasise those in favour of your case and answer those adverse to it.