AH0330 - Appeals Handbook - Settlement of Appeals by Agreement: Withdrawal of appeal


If the appellant says he wishes to withdraw his appeal he is effectively saying that the amendment, assessment, direction, decision or determination under appeal should remain as it is and not be varied. If you do not object to the withdrawal of the appeal it can be settled by an agreement that the amendment, assessment, decision or determination should be upheld.

If the appellant gives notice in writing that he wishes to withdraw his appeal and you do not object to the withdrawal of the appeal write to the appellant to confirm your agreement to the amendment, assessment, decision or determination being upheld. Unless you notify him within thirty days of the date of the notification that you object to the withdrawal, the appeal is regarded as having been settled by agreement by both parties at the date of the appellant's notification of withdrawal.

If the appellant orally gives notice that he wishes to withdraw his appeal ask him to confirm it in writing. If the confirmation is not forthcoming immediately you should take the initiative and formally confirm the oral withdrawal of the appeal and HMRC’s agreement to the amendment, assessment, decision or determination being upheld. The appeal is regarded as having been settled by agreement by both parties at the date you issued written confirmation that the withdrawal was accepted.

Following the withdrawal of an appeal against an assessment or amendment and acceptance of the withdrawal the assessment or amendment is treated as confirmed by the Commissioners. Therefore, if there is reason to believe that the profits or gains exceed the assessment, you should notify the appellant within 30 days that you object to the withdrawal of the appeal in good time and proceed to ascertain the correct amount assessable. Failure to meet this time limit may prevent you from ultimately assessing the correct liability.